Consignment & Thrift Shops
Lancaster/Mountville/Columbia Area

Here is a listing of Consignment and Thrift Shops in the Lancaster/Mountville/Columbia area. Purchasing items from one of the many Lancaster PA Consignment Shops and Local Thrift Stores is a great way to save money in today's economy. Feel free to add a comment/review of a particular store or add a store that has been missed here, or read the reviews/comments of others.

Salvation Army Family Store
1244 Manheim Pike
Open Mon-Sat 9-9

Salvation Army thrift stores are loaded with gently used clothing and household items that are donated through our pick up service, drop-off bins, community centers and family stores. Fresh clothing, furniture and household items arrive daily and the proceeds from these sales fund our adult rehabilitation program, which helps over 216,000 people every year. These stores offer shoppers the opportunity to purchase quality clothing, furniture, household goods, sporting equipment, books, electronics and much more at bargain prices.

Whether you are looking for an amazing deal on brand name goods, searching for a rare treasure or antique, or simply looking to purchase great products from a store that helps those in need, The Salvation Army store is the place for you. Your purchase helps The Salvation Army recycle goods to recycle lives.

Goodwill Store & Donation Center
Regency Square Shopping Center
121 Rohrerstown Rd.
Open M-Th 9-8, Fri-Sat 9-9, Sun 12-5

A Treasure Hunter's Paradise... Enjoy Value and Unique Items by Shopping Goodwill Retail Stores

Every day, every aisle at Goodwill thrift stores is stocked with thousands of gently used and new items. Designer labels, hip vintage styles, and household goods at bargain prices are just part of why savvy consumers shop Goodwill. Our stores are bright, colorful, and well organized, making it easy to browse through our large selection of merchandise. But shopping Goodwill thrift stores doesn't just offer good value, and good selection. Your purchases divert items from landfill and support our mission to provide job training and placement programs for individuals with disabilities and other vocational disadvantages. Now that's Good For Everyone!

Second Lancaster location:
2353 Lincoln Hwy. E.
Open Mon-Sat 9-9, Sun 11-6

Déjà Vu Consignment Boutique
1521A Lititz Pike (right off Route 30 near Lancaster Shopping Center - behind AC Moore)
Open Tu,W,F,Sat 10-5, Th 10-7

Déjà vu offers consignment shopping at its best, with a meticulously-organized shop showcasing trendy, like-new clothing! Brands include Ann Taylor, Chicos, Limited, Talbots, NY&Co., Express, Coldwater Creek, etc. New jewelry and beautiful new scarves and handbags at great prices. Open over 20 years, offering only the most current women's clothing and accessories in excellent condition.

Thrifty Elegance
1708 Columbia Ave.
Open Thursday-Saturday 10-7 and Sunday 11-4

Thrifty Elegance is located on the corner of Columbia Avenue and Albright Avenue, and the entrance is on Albright. Selling household items, home decor, vintage and antique items, books, jewelry, primitive items, man cave items, furniture and kitchenware.
Offering pick up of consigned furniture.
Visit Thrifty Elegance on Facebook - like us to see specials.
Email us at

Next to New Fine Furniture Consignment Shop
1929 Lincoln Hwy (Garden Spot Square)
Open M-W 10-6, Th 10-8, Fri 10-6, Sat 10-5, Sun 12-4 (Lincoln Hwy Store)

Offering high quality consigned merchandise for 35+ years: furniture, artwork, antiques, lamps, home accessories, china, glassware, jewelry and collectibles. Offering pickup and delivery for single items or entire households.

2 other locations:
41 S Broad St., Lititz 717-625-4566
2119 New Holland Pike, Lancaster 717-509-4499

K&A Used Appliances
50 Redwood Dr.
Open M-Fri 9-7, Sat 9-2

We sell quality used appliances: washers, dryers, refrigerators, ranges and new air conditioners. Every appliance is tested and comes with a 90 day warranty. Delivery and removal of old appliane is available for small additional charge ($25 for most locations). We also have another location at 318 E. Main St., New Holland 717-656-2330

Miracles Consignment
3545 Marietta Ave (Silver Spring Plaza)
Open M,Tu,W 10-5, Th,Fri 10-7, Sat 10-3

Everything for your Newborn to Teenage Miracle. Specializing in new & gently worn Preemie through Junior - clothing, shoes & accessories. Also offering maternity wear & nursing care, baby gear, equipment & furniture, bedding, toys, books, games, puzzles, DVD's & more. All things child related.

Stock Swap Furniture Consignments
375 Highland Dr
Open M,Tu,W, Th 10-5, Fri 10-7, Sat 10-5

Lancaster's oldest furniture consignment business, with 34 years of experience, offers the finest used home furnishings in the area from the area's best homes. With thousands of items in stock, clean & beautifully displayed, you will find sofas, chairs, end tables, coffee tables, dining & kitchen sets (formal & informal), antiques, crystal, china, lamps, rugs, mirrors, artwork & many home decorator accessories & a great selection of jewelry. It's quality home furnishings bargain shopping at its best!

New to You Consignments of Mountville
119 Oak Ridge Dr
Open Tu & W 10-4, Th & Fri 10-7, Sat 10-4

Carrying quality name brand clothes for the entire family from newborn to plus sizes.

Ooh La La Consignment
3014 Columbia Ave. (Rt 462 - close to BJ's, just off Centerville Rd.)
Open Tu,Th,Fr 10-5:30, W 10-7, Sat 10-3

An upscale consignment boutique with merchandise artfully displayed in a beautiful home built in the early 1900's with crystal chandeliers throughout. In addition to high quality, like-new women's and teen girl's clothing, you will also find new & used jewelry, scarves, handbags (like Coach & Kate Spade) and shoes.

Resale Therapy Consignment Boutique
420 W Grant St
Lancaster, PA 17603
More Information

Columbia Re-Uzit Shop
363 Locust St.
Open M,Tu,W,Th,Sat 9-4, Fr 9-7
Winter Hours (Jan, Feb, March) Open Mon-Sat 9-4

An MCC Thrift Shop filled with affordable treasures: clothing, toys, books, furniture, housewares, bedding, some electronics and more. You'll find brand name items without paying a name brand price. Proceeds are used locally & globally to meet basic human needs through the MCC.

Additional consignment and thrift shops in Lancaster County:

Didn't find what you were looking for?
Use this search feature to find it.

Related Pages